The best guideline would be that a damaged card that is clearly still tournament legal should be graded Light Played, and one clearly not tournament legal would be Poor
Grade: C Mazzy, Truesword Paladin Mazzy, Truesword Paladin is a brave halfling fighter who serves Arvoreen, the halfling god of war and protection
Its first chapter provides a situational Oblivion RingOblivion Ring, its next two chapters provide a temporary PropagandaPropaganda to help thwart go-wide strategies, and its final chapter lets you net some Treasure tokens so long as at least one of your opponents has a creature with power four or greater
But since Hobgoblin Bandit Lord pumps up the whole board and has an activated ability that can win the game with one good turn, standard goblins is now a going concern
Here are a few jokes in this cycle: Head to Head This card shows Braids being interrogated in a police-style interrogation room
While also making one of your creatures indestructible, every point of damage that would normally hurt it instead converts to +1/+1 counters, quickly building it into a massive threat