mtg mono blue commander deck Wizard - - EDH - 100 Card - Custom Magic The Gathering Deck MTG Commander Deck EDH Deck

In isolation I rate this as the best of this Charm cycle but sadly it is in Selesnya which is a less popular and diverse colour pairing than most others which brings this more in line with the other good ones

Nightmare Shepherd Nightmare Shepherd shines in decks with lots of good ETB creatures, so you can make copies of them and profit twice

In fact, many people assumed that it was on the Reserved List

If it doesnt and your opponent decides to use a removal spell on it, youll gain another three life for your trouble

Honestly, I doubt it will ever be more than an interesting one-of or two-of in someones sideboard

Something like "I had eggs for breakfast" is fine